"No food to eat. My farm has been washed away by floods."
Construction
of dams has increased in recent years from around 5,000 large
dams in 1949 in countries, increasing to over 45,000 large dams by 2000 in over
150 countries (Altinbilek, 2002). (Figure
2). Societal needs for water have changed, so power production through
hydropower has become key for countries to develop further.
Figure 2: The increase of dams in Ghana from 1900-1990. |
Now onto the video from the beginning of this post! Ghana, along with many countries
around the world are seeing failing dams due to the altered rainfall patterns
leading to increased and more intensive flooding. Ghana is not the only country to be experiencing these increases in flooding, climate change is altering rainfall patterns and dams cannot cope. Studies show that dams do aid flood control, but seasonal predictable flooding- not large-scale unprecedented flooding (Boulange et al., 2021). Increased precipitation leads to higher levels of water from surface runoff as well as rainfall (Grill et al., 2019). The dams in Ghana were manually opened to prevent a catastrophic amount of flooding- although I would argue it didn't necessarily do this- as the water levels were less than half a foot away from being over the safe operational level.
There are many economic benefits from dams, however there are negative social and environmental effects, with ecosystems and houses destroyed, and rivers regimes being altered (Altinbilek, 2002). In fact only 23% of rivers globally flow undisrupted to the sea (Grill et al., 2019).
A Ghanian resident, Brian Foekpa, expressed, "No food to eat. My farm has been washed away by the floods. As I'm talking to you, these clothes I have on me now are the only ones I have." Despite local authorities' warnings, no one predicted the damage the spillage would create for over 100 communities.
Manmade dams have an uncertain future due to climate
change with no guarantees how they’ll react. Scientists are predicting that
natural rivers will in fact adapt better (Altinbilek, 2002). There are many factors which will influence Africa’s
climate- stay tuned for future posts!
A video that captures the devastating impacts of flooding well...
ReplyDeleteHowever, with Africas very often transboundary issues damming is a very common form of management.
Do you think dams are a bad form of management if it results in problems such as this? or do you think that they are more positive than negative?
Hi Lily! It was a very upsetting story to read about with the amount of lives which were upturned and destroyed.
DeleteIt is a tricky question to answer. Dams create a lot of controversy right from when they are built, with the sociological and environmental effects. But can lead to a secure water source, but like you said often it leads to further upset between territories over who has the right to access the water or even if they have the right to build a dam which leads to more problems. Such as those in the videos, as many people are involved in the management so who takes accountability of these? In the past I believe they were more positive than negative, but with increased rainfall patterns management needs to be changed as if scenarios like this occur more often the negative effects will the make the positive negligible.
Hi Beth,
ReplyDeleteI really like the idea of using a quote from a resident as the title of this blogpost. It is innovative and it really allows readers to feel the impact of floods on people's life and livelihoods. It reminds people that this is not just theoretical debate on the Internet, it is tragedies actually happening in the real world. I enjoyed reading your blog!
Hi Priscilla, thank you! I feel it is important to situate our knowledge within real lives scenarios to bring them to live like you said. It allows us to think more and sympathise for everyone effected, while making us think deeper about this topic as we can understand the direct social impacts of these events.
DeleteHi Beth! I really liked how your blog drew on the topical example of the floods in Ghana which highlight just how important it is to understand these topics and spread an understanding of these issues. You mentioned that climate change is altering precipitation patterns. I was wondering, what are the specific changes happening that are affecting dams and causing them to flood more? How does this risk of flooding vary seasonally and are there any phenomenon which relate to this?
ReplyDeleteThanks Safiyah! The main change is the unpredictable rainfall events in the months prior to the flood having lead to the dam overflowing. Due to the limited capacities of these dams, companies have to adhere to an safe operational level before the decide on a spillage (which is an intentional flood) to keep from a extreme flood. In this case there was a lack of appropriate management on top of these unforeseen quantities of rainfall. The Volta River Authorities and power companies claimed to have adequately warned local communities about potentially flooding, but this clearly did not prepare communities when 8,000 people had to be requeued by the Ghanian navy, and so many more lost their livelihoods and homes.
DeleteThe reasons for these unpredictable rainfall patterns is due to temperatures increasing, which lead to alterations in the atmospheric circulation, leading to changes in El Nino and La Nina events. The former leads to much dryer spells, where as the latter can lead to more rainfall. There is seasonal variation of rainfall due to these events, with Ghana having a wet season in June to September and then a dry season, with flooding events taking place in the wet season. But also within Ghana there is spatial variation of rainfall patterns. Coastal, southern Ghana gets more rainfall than northern Ghana which is further from the sea, as sea water is evaporated leaving heavy, dense rainclouds which fall over the southern communities. Stay tuned for more on these events as I will discuss them further in my blogs!
Hello again Beth. I enjoyed this post even more than the last one! The specific focus on the dam in Ghana allowed for an emotive read, even in just a short blog post. I was wondering if you could outline the main benefits and negatives of dams more generally in relation to water in Africa?
ReplyDeleteHello again Charlotte! Thank you for the question, as it is something touched on only in relation to Ghana in my blog, when in fact the positives and negatives of dams may vary across each dam.
DeleteBenefits of dams are:
- a source of water through the dry seasons or droughts
- hydroelectricity as a source of renewable energy
- large scale irrigation from water funnelled from the dams reservoirs
- preventing flooding (of course not the case in Ghana)
Negatives of dams are:
- the construction damages ecology
- changes to the floodplains effects soil quality due to no minerals and nutrients being deposited each wet season
- conflicts emerge over dams, between countries as well as locally, over who get the priority of the water
- often not managed or maintained properly which can lead to deaths or infrastructural damage
In no way am I saying dams should not be constructed or built, but proper thought needs to be invested into how to keep these dams efficient with the changing climates. Evaporation may increase meaning some reservoirs will loose water, other dams may spill due to higher precipitation. Adequate data is needed to monitor how these dams need to be adapted.